Benefits of a Postnup in California – Why Get a Postnuptial Agreement?

postnuptial agreement benefits for a happy marriage

Postnuptial Agreements in California: Why You May Need One

Bringing up a postnuptial agreement can feel awkward. Many spouses worry it will sound like a lack of trust. In our experience it often works the other way. Couples who settle money questions calmly, while things are good, often find it takes pressure off the marriage. A postnup lets you decide how property, income, debts and support would be handled if the marriage ended, instead of leaving those questions to California’s default rules. And you make those decisions while you are both thinking clearly, not reacting to a crisis.

If you are considering one, talk with a lawyer before you sign anything. Scott Levin is a postnuptial agreement lawyer in San Diego who works with couples in two ways: as a neutral mediator who helps you build the agreement together, or as one spouse’s own attorney.

On this page (8 sections)
  1. Postnuptial Agreements in California: Why You May Need One
  2. What Is a Postnuptial Agreement?
  3. What a Postnup Can’t Do
  4. What Are the Benefits of a Postnup in California?
  5. Who Needs a Postnuptial Agreement?
  6. Is a Postnup Harder to Enforce Than a Prenup?
  7. Do You Need a Postnup Lawyer for a Postnuptial Agreement?
  8. Talk With Scott About a Postnup
postnuptial agreement benefits for a happy marriage

What Is a Postnuptial Agreement?

A postnuptial agreement, also called a postmarital agreement, is a written contract between spouses signed after the wedding. It serves much the same purpose as a prenuptial agreement, but California law treats the two differently, and that difference shapes how a postnup should be prepared (more on that below).

A postnup can address:

  • Which property is separate and which is community, including what each of you owned before the marriage and gifts or inheritances received during it
  • How earnings, savings and investments built during the marriage will be treated
  • Responsibility for debts
  • A business: ownership, growth in value, owner pay and buyout terms
  • Equity compensation such as RSUs and stock options
  • Reimbursement when one spouse puts separate money into a home or another shared asset
  • Spousal support, within important limits
  • How the agreement fits with each spouse’s estate plan

What a Postnup Can’t Do

  • Decide child custody or limit child support. Custody is decided based on the children’s best interests, and child support under California’s statewide guideline, at the time the issue comes up. Parents can’t waive or limit a child’s right to support. Terms that try to settle these in advance won’t bind a court.
  • Penalize marital misconduct. California is a no-fault divorce state. Courts have refused to enforce marital agreements that impose a financial penalty for infidelity (Diosdado v. Diosdado (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 470) or that shift property to one spouse if the other uses drugs (In re Marriage of Mehren & Dargan (2004) 118 Cal.App.4th 1167). A postnup can be part of rebuilding trust after a hard period, but it can’t punish an affair or other conduct.
  • Replace estate planning or retirement-plan paperwork. Waiving survivor benefits in most private-employer retirement plans requires the plan’s own spousal consent form, signed before a notary or plan representative and timed under the plan’s rules, so a postnup usually can’t serve as that waiver. Waivers of a spouse’s rights at death have their own requirements under California’s Probate Code. A postnup should be coordinated with your wills, trusts and beneficiary designations.

What Are the Benefits of a Postnup in California?

The value of a postnup depends on whether it fits your marriage and your finances. These are the benefits couples most often look for.

Clarity About What’s Separate and What’s Shared

Over time, separate and community money tends to blend. A premarital account receives paychecks, or an inheritance helps pay down the mortgage. A postnup can record what each of you considers separate, what is shared and how contributions will be credited, so neither of you has to reconstruct years of records later.

Protection for an Inheritance or Gift

Under California law, property a spouse receives by gift or inheritance is generally that spouse’s separate property. It can still become hard to trace once it is mixed with marital funds or used toward a shared home. A postnup can document what is separate and set out how any contribution to a shared asset will be treated.

You may also hear the term transmutation agreement. A transmutation changes the character of specific property, for example turning a separate account into community property, or the reverse. A postnup is usually broader. But any part of a postnup that changes the character of property is a transmutation, so it must meet the same rule: an express written declaration made, joined in, consented to or accepted by the spouse whose interest is adversely affected (Family Code § 852).

A Plan for a Business

If one or both of you own a business, a postnup can set out how the business and its growth in value will be treated, how owner pay and retained earnings are handled, and whether a buyout would apply. The right terms depend on when and how the business started and what each spouse contributes to it.

RSUs, Stock Options and Other Equity

Equity compensation often vests years after it is granted, which makes it one of the harder assets to divide. A postnup can set a clear rule for awards granted or vesting during the marriage. Because Scott is also a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst®, he can show you how a proposed rule would work out on your actual numbers before you agree to it.

Financial Security for Both Spouses

A postnup isn’t only for the higher-earning spouse. It can recognize a spouse who steps back from a career to raise children or to support the other’s education, set reimbursement terms for separate money put into the family home, and address support. Spousal support terms need especially careful drafting and independent advice. California law on support terms in a postnup is less settled than for a prenup, so a court may look closely at them or decline to enforce them.

Fewer Disputes If the Marriage Ends

When the major financial questions are already settled in a valid agreement, a divorce tends to be shorter, less expensive and less contentious. You still divide anything the agreement doesn’t cover, but there is far less to fight about.

Less Pressure on the Marriage

Money disagreements that keep coming back, about spending, debt or how a windfall should be treated, can wear on a marriage. Putting a clear plan in writing often ends the argument. A postnup should never be signed under threats or used as leverage.

Who Needs a Postnuptial Agreement?

Many married couples can benefit, and a postnup is especially worth considering in these situations:

  • Blended families. If either of you has children from a prior relationship, a postnup coordinated with your estate plan can help make sure property you intend for them, such as a vacation home you owned before this marriage, goes where you mean it to.
  • A big change in finances. An inheritance, a business that takes off or a large equity award.
  • Buying real estate or other major assets, especially with separate money.
  • Unequal contributions. One spouse contributes much more financially, or puts separate funds into a shared asset.
  • A career change or pause. One spouse steps back from work or supports the other’s education or career.
  • Different approaches to money. Spending or debt has become a recurring source of conflict.
  • After a difficult period. Some couples sign a postnup as part of recommitting to the marriage. That can work, as long as the agreement deals with finances rather than penalties and both spouses sign freely.

Is a Postnup Harder to Enforce Than a Prenup?

Generally, yes. Before the wedding, future spouses aren’t presumed to be in a confidential relationship, and prenups are governed by California’s Premarital Agreement Act. Once you are married, you owe each other fiduciary duties of the highest good faith and fair dealing (Family Code § 721). If a postnup gives one spouse an advantage over the other, courts generally presume it resulted from undue influence. The spouse who benefits then has to show it was signed freely and voluntarily, with full knowledge of the facts and a complete understanding of its effect.

That doesn’t make postnups unreliable. It means the process matters as much as the terms. A postnup stands on much firmer ground when:

  • It is in writing and signed by both spouses. Oral agreements about property aren’t enough, and any change in ownership needs the express written declaration described above.
  • Both spouses give complete, honest disclosure of their income, assets and debts.
  • Neither spouse is pressured. Each has time to read the draft, ask questions and get advice, and no one signs because of threats or ultimatums.
  • Each spouse has an independent lawyer advise them before signing.
  • The terms make sense for both spouses, and the reasons for any imbalance are understood.

For comparison, see the requirements for California prenups.

Does a Postnup Have to Be Notarized?

No. California doesn’t require notarization for a postnup to be valid between the spouses. What matters is that it is in writing, signed by both of you, and made with full disclosure and without pressure. Signatures are often notarized anyway, as a record of who signed and when. Some related steps have their own rules: changing ownership of real property may call for a recorded deed (which must be notarized to be recorded) so the change is effective against third parties, and a private-employer plan’s survivor-benefit waiver must be witnessed by a notary or plan representative.

Can We Change It Later?

Yes. A postnup can be amended or revoked by a new written agreement signed by both spouses, prepared with the same disclosure and care as the original.

Do You Need a Postnup Lawyer for a Postnuptial Agreement?

California law doesn’t require each spouse to have a lawyer before signing a postnup. But an agreement signed without independent advice is much easier to challenge later, especially if it favors one spouse. That’s why Scott requires each spouse to have independent counsel before anyone signs.

Can you share one lawyer to save money? Not as your shared attorney. Spouses negotiating a postnup have different interests, so one lawyer shouldn’t represent both of you, and your spouse’s attorney can’t advise you. There are two ways to work with Scott:

  • Postnup mediation. Scott acts as a neutral mediator. He represents neither of you, helps you work through the terms together and drafts the agreement from your decisions. Each of you then has your own independent attorney review it before signing.
  • Representation. Scott advises one spouse, drafts or reviews the agreement and negotiates on that spouse’s behalf. The other spouse has their own lawyer.

Talk With Scott About a Postnup

Scott Levin, Esq., CDFA®, has been a California attorney since 2004 and has conducted 2,500+ mediations. As both an attorney and a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst®, he can explain the legal limits of a postnup and the financial effect of the terms you are considering, before you commit to anything. If you missed the chance to sign a prenup, it isn’t too late to put a clear plan in place.

Schedule a free 15-minute consultation with San Diego Divorce Mediation & Family Law, or call 858-293-1410.

This article is general information, not legal advice. The right terms depend on your specific facts.

Want to talk through your situation? Book a free 15-minute introductory call.On the booking page, choose “15 Minute Consultation Call.” Paid sessions, such as the Divorce Strategy Session, are listed separately.

By Published On: November 1st, 2024